Aaron Samuels: Drew Fuller
Chloe Drake: Sarah Carter
Christina Ballard: Ashanti
David Weaver: Ian Somerholder
Kleopatra Al-Shar: Lacey Chabert
Matthew Summers: Chad Michael Murray
Michael Smith: Milo Ventimiglia
Nathan Grey: Forbes March
Roxanne Hivers: Kate Beckinsale
Sophie Livensten: Emilie Autumn

Alden Samuels: David Gallagher
Ashley Carson: Lindsay Lohan
Bianca Fishlen: Marisol Nichols
Lucas Baker: Jared Padalecki
Karl Livensten: Karl Urban
Max Ballard: Scott Vickaryous
Nolee Black: Wendi Kenya

Brian Smith: Freddie Prinze Jr.
Julia Stiles: Julia Stiles
Lucy Watson: Victoria Pratt
Rea Pride: Jessica Biel
Selene Stiles-Smith: Sophia Myles
Victor Livensten: Karl Urban